A research-led redesign of ShopGoodwill’s category navigation and shopping interface, designed to help secondhand shoppers discover, filter, and explore items more easily.

ShopGoodwill redesigned homepage shown on a laptop

Industry

Secondhand E-commerce

Audience

Secondhand shoppers

Team

Team Thrifty · 5 designers

My Role

Research, UX / UI Design, Prototyping

Overview

ShopGoodwill is an online secondhand marketplace. Over 10 weeks, our five-person team explored how clearer navigation and more readable shopping interfaces could help people find items. I focused on research, UI design, and prototyping, translating our findings into the redesigned shopping experience.

Problem

ShopGoodwill’s 250+ category menus made finding items difficult. Confusing labels, deep navigation, and overly specific categories increased the effort of browsing. Our challenge was to make the marketplace easier to explore while preserving the sense of discovery that draws people to secondhand shopping.

Research & Insights

Our team combined competitive research, a heuristic evaluation, a closed card sort with 3 participants, and two rounds of tree testing with 12 and 7 participants. The findings pointed to overwhelming category choices, ambiguous labels, and subcategories that would work better as filters. These insights shaped both the navigation and the shopping interface.

Design Goal

How might we help secondhand shoppers find relevant items with less navigation effort? Organize categories around shopper expectations, make filtering easier to scan, and support clear next steps from browsing to item details.

Information Architecture

The team’s final sitemap organizes shopping into seven top-level categories: Antiques, Books, Clothing, Collectibles, Entertainment, Home & Furniture, and Toys & Games. Each branches into more specific subcategories to guide browsing. Books became a standalone category rather than sitting under Entertainment, creating a direct entry point for fiction, nonfiction, textbooks, children’s books, and comics. This structure informed the category navigation UI.

Tree Testing

The team evaluated a sitemap with 7 main categories, 46 subcategories, and 253 tertiary categories. Two tree-testing rounds used the same 10 tasks to compare findability. Moving Books to the top level improved textbook discovery, while the boundary between Antiques and Collectibles remained unclear.

01 / Overall success

60.8% → 64.3%

Round 1: 12 participants · Round 2: 7 participants

02 / Task efficiency

7.3 seconds faster

Reduction in mean task time across rounds

03 / Books at the top level

33% → 100% task success

Math textbook task · Round 2 mean time: 9.2 seconds

04 / Unresolved findability

Clarify Antiques vs. Collectibles

Map task: 67% → 29% success · Revisit labels and cross-listing

01 / Research to interface

Make discovery easier.

Our research revealed a gap between the appeal of treasure hunting and the effort of navigating the site. I focused on translating these findings into UI and prototype decisions: clearer entry points, more readable product information, and a consistent structure across the shopping journey.

02 / Category navigation

A clearer path to every find.

A horizontal category bar and multi-column flyout menus replace the dropdown-heavy navigation. Clearer grouping and visual hierarchy help shoppers scan the available paths. The UI makes the team’s revised information architecture visible and easier to explore.

ShopGoodwill category navigation with multi-column flyout menus

03 / Filtering & browsing

Narrow the search. Keep the discovery.

Filters for brand, price, size, color, condition, listing type, and location help shoppers narrow a broad inventory. An interactive store map supports local browsing and pickup planning. These views give shoppers more control without relying on increasingly specific navigation categories.

ShopGoodwill filtering controls and local store map

04 / Homepage & visual hierarchy

Give every section a clear purpose.

The homepage organizes discovery through category pills, featured items, trending products, and recommendations. Consistent spacing, typography, and content grouping help shoppers distinguish navigation from merchandise and move through the page with a clearer sense of what to explore next.

ShopGoodwill homepage layout and content hierarchy

05 / Product information

Make the details easier to compare.

Item listings bring size badges, condition tags, and quick-bid or buy-now actions into view. Product pages add a condition details callout and related-item recommendations. Clear, specific language supports these decisions, reflecting the team’s UX writing research.

ShopGoodwill product listing, item details, cart, and account screens

06 / Prototyping & next steps

Connect the screens into a journey.

I focused on prototyping alongside research and UI design, connecting the redesigned shopping screens into a coherent experience. The next step is to evaluate complete browsing and purchase tasks, while revisiting ambiguous category labels and cross-listing items that fit more than one shopper expectation.

ShopGoodwill sign-in, bid confirmation, cart, and notification interface states

Reflection

This project connected research, UI design, and prototyping in my process. Clearer screens depend on understandable categories as well as visual hierarchy. The team’s second tree test improved overall findability, but some tasks regressed. Those results reinforced the need to test specific decisions and keep unresolved problems visible.